Correcting acid soil conditions through the application of lime can have a significant impact on crop yields, especially alfalfa. Since seeding alfalfa is expensive and a stand is expected to last for several years, getting lime applied and acidity corrected before seeding is critical. Liming is one of the most essential, but often overlooked, management decisions a producer can make.
Unfortunately lime is not always available close to where it may be needed. In many cases trucking and spreading costs may be more than the cost of the lime itself. Lime quality can also vary widely and no one wants to apply more than is necessary. So to make the best decisions on how much and what kind of lime to apply, it is useful to know how lime recommendations are made.
How lime recommendations are made by K-State
A routine soil test will reveal the pH level of the soil, and this will determine whether lime is needed on the field. Generally, east of the Flint Hills, lime is recommended for alfalfa if the pH drops below 6.4, with a target pH for liming of 6.8. In the Flint Hills and west, lime is recommended for alfalfa and all other crops when the pH drops below 5.8, with a target pH of 6.0. Target pH is simply the pH goal once the lime reacts with the soil.
Why are the target pHs different for the two areas of Kansas? They differ because of the pH of the subsoil. East of the Flint Hills, especially south of the Kansas River, the subsoil tends to be acidic, and a higher target pH is used to assure adequate pH conditions in the root zone, and provide sufficient amounts of calcium and magnesium. From the Flint Hills west, most soils have high-pH, basic subsoils that can provide additional calcium and magnesium to meet crop needs.
Soils with more clay and organic matter will have more reserve acidity at a given pH, and will require more ECC (effective calcium carbonate) to reach a target soil pH, than will a sandy soil. This is why two soils may have the same soil pH but have quite different buffer pHs, and different lime requirements.
Calculating lime rates
Lime rates are given in pounds of effective calcium carbonate, ECC, per acre, but how does that relate to agricultural lime and how much lime to apply? Lime materials can vary widely in their neutralizing power. All lime materials sold in Kansas must guarantee their ECC content and dealers are subject to inspection by the Kansas Department of Agriculture.
The two factors that influence neutralizing value are the chemical neutralizing value of the lime material relative to pure calcium carbonate, and the fineness of crushing, or particle size, of the product. These two factors are used in the determination of ECC. The surface area of the particles is critical for neutralizing to occur. Expressing recommendations as pounds of ECC allows fine-tuning of rates for variation in lime sources, and avoids under- or over-applying lime products.
Research has clearly shown that a pound of ECC from agricultural lime, pelletized lime, water treatment plant sludge, fluid lime, or other sources is equal in neutralizing soil acidity. Therefore under most circumstances, the cost per pound of ECC applied to your field should be a primary factor in source selection. Other factors such as rate of reaction (fineness), uniformity of spreading, and availability should be considered, but the final pH change, and subsequent alfalfa growth, will depend on the amount of ECC applied.
All lime sources have a very limited solubility and when planting alfalfa, best performance is obtained when lime is incorporated and given time to react with and neutralize the acidity in the soil. When surface applied and not incorporated, as in no-till systems, the reaction of lime is generally limited to only neutralizing the acidity and raising the pH in the top 2 to 3 inches of soil. Surface applications are adequate in slightly acidic soils, but may not provide as good a soil environment for nodulation and nitrogen fixation in the extremely acid soils, pH below 5.0, currently found in some soils in Kansas.
In no-till or limited-till systems, where no incorporation of lime is planned, lower rates of lime application are normally recommended to avoid over-liming and raising the pH higher than needed in the surface 2-3 inches of soil. Over-liming can also reduce the availability of micronutrients such as zinc, iron, and manganese, and trigger deficiencies in some soils. Current K-State lime recommendations suggest that “traditional” rates designed for incorporation and mixing with the top 6 inches of soil should be reduced by 50 to 60 percent when surface applied in no-till systems, or when applied to existing grass or alfalfa stands.
Calcium and magnesium contents
What about the calcium and magnesium contents? Most agricultural limes found in Kansas contain both calcium and magnesium, though the relative concentrations of the two essential plant nutrients varies widely. While the advantages and disadvantages of using a dolomitic (magnesium-containing) lime versus a calcitic (low-magnesium, high-calcium) lime have been cussed and discussed for years, the differences are very, very slight in most cases. The exception is on soils deficient in magnesium, in which case a dolomitic lime source is needed. In Kansas, both dolomitic lime and calcitic lime are suitable for use on cropland.
For more information, see K-State publication Soil Test Interpretations and Fertilizer Recommendations, MF-2586: http://www.bookstore.ksre.ksu.edu/pubs/MF2586.pdf
Dave Mengel, Soil Fertility Specialist
Dorivar Ruiz Diaz, Nutrient Management Specialist