There are now several 2-gene Clearfield wheat varieties on the market: AP503 CL2 from Syngenta/AgriPro, Brawl CL Plus from Colorado State University, Doublestop CL Plus from Oklahoma State University, and WB-Deuce CL Plus from Monsanto/WestBred. More such varieties will no doubt be on the market in the coming years.
What is the difference between these varieties and the original 1-gene Clearfield varieties in terms of how they can be managed, herbicide applications, grass control, and crop injury?
There is no difference in the labeled rates of Beyond that can be applied in a single growing season to 1-gene and 2-gene Clearfield varieties. However, methylated seed oil (MSO) or crop oil concentrate (COC) can be added as an adjuvant to Beyond when it is used on 2-gene Clearfield varieties. On 1-gene Clearfield varieties, only a non-ionic surfactant (NIS) can be used as an adjuvant. In cases, a nitrogen-based fertilizer such as AMS or 28 percent UAN should also be added to the spray solution.
The adjuvant can make a significant difference in the level of feral rye and downy brome control with Beyond, especially with spring treatments. Since cheat, Japanese brome, and jointed goatgrass are usually quite susceptible to Beyond, the adjuvant usually does not make as much difference in the level of control of these grasses. A recent K-State study near Manhattan illustrates the effect.
|
Winter Annual Grass Control and Crop Response in 2-gene Clearfield Wheat |
||||||
|
Treatment |
Application rate (oz/acre) |
Application timing |
Wheat injury (%) |
Japanese brome control (%) |
Downy brome control (%) |
Rye control (%) |
|
Beyond + NIS + AMS |
4 |
Fall |
0 |
100 |
99 |
95 |
|
Beyond + MSO + AMS |
4 |
Fall |
0 |
100 |
99 |
100 |
|
Beyond + MSO + AMS |
6 |
Fall |
0 |
100 |
100 |
100 |
|
Beyond + MSO + AMS |
12 (2x) |
Fall |
0 |
100 |
100 |
100 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Beyond + NIS + AMS |
4 |
Spring |
0 |
98 |
75 |
57 |
|
Beyond + MSO + AMS |
4 |
Spring |
0 |
99 |
82 |
78 |
|
Beyond + MSO + AMS |
6 |
Spring |
0 |
100 |
91 |
93 |
|
Beyond + MSO + AMS |
12 (2x) |
Spring |
0 |
100 |
97 |
100 |
|
LSD (0.05) |
|
|
NS |
NS |
4 |
11 |
Note: The maximum single application use rate of Beyond is 6 oz/acre. The 12 oz/acre rate would simulate spray overlaps in the field and is not a labeled broadcast application rate.
For spring applications of Beyond, including MSO as an adjuvant measurably improved control of downy brome and feral rye compared to using NIS as the adjuvant. But as mentioned above, Beyond with MSO can only be used on 2-gene Clearfield varieties. MSO has been more effective than COC in these situations.
Beyond is labeled for control of many winter annual grasses (including jointed goatgrass, cheat, downy brome, and Japanese brome), but only suppression of feral rye. Control of feral rye with Beyond in K-State tests has been somewhat erratic and unpredictable. The best control will likely be achieved with fall applications, using the 6 oz rate instead of the 4 oz rate, and using MSO instead of NIS where that is allowed. In general, the best control of feral rye in 1-gene Clearfield varieties has been with fall applications. With 2-gene Clearfield varieties, producers now have more options for better rye control.
The other advantage of 2-gene Clearfield over 1-gene Clearfield wheat varieties is in the higher degree of crop safety from applications of Beyond. Occasionally, Beyond has caused some crop injury to 1-gene Clearfield wheat. This occurs most often where there is spray overlap (2x rates), when stress conditions prevail, or where wheat was not at the recommended treatment stages at the time of application. In K-State tests, 2-gene Clearfield wheat varieties have demonstrated much less potential for crop injury than 1-gene varieties in these situations.
Dallas Peterson, Weed Management Specialist
dpeterso@ksu.edu
Tags: